Preorder your Pies & Cakes!

The holidays are here! Preorder your Caribbean Pie Company pies, Hershey’s© Ice Cream Cakes, and Ice Cream Pies.

Pies are prepared without a whipped topping. If you would like yours to come with a shell border of our very own delicious whipped topping, please note it in the Message Section.
🍌 Banana Salted Caramel Pie
Sea Salt, Caramel, and Banana all infused together.
🍈 Classic Key Lime Pie
Award-Winning Key Lime pie in a graham cracker crust. 
🍫 Chocolate Silk Pie
Oreo crust, bottom layer of chocolate ganache topped with a light and fluffy chocolate mousse & chocolate shavings covering the top
🥭 Tropical Key Lime Pie
Graham cracker crust, Raspberry, Mango, and Guava swirled into the top layer of key lime.
🥥 Coconut Cream Pie
Graham cracker crust, super-creamy intense coconut cream filling with shredded coconut and topped with toasted coconut.
🍎 Apple Crumb Pie
Fresh apple slices in a pastry crust with a buttery crumb topping.
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
Traditional Pumpkin Pie, silky pumpkin filling, surrounded by a buttery flaky crust.
🍂 Classic Southern Pecan Pie
Classic Pecan Pie with the perfect amount of sweet, both soft and crunchy filling. Contains 2 cups of pecans throughout the pie.
🍡 Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Key Lime Pie slice on a stick  dipped in Belgian chocolate.
🍦 Large Hershey’s© Ice Cream Sheet Cake – Serves 18-26 | $28.18
🍦 7″ Round Hershey’s© Ice Cream Cake – Serves 8-10 | $16.13
🍦 7″ Oreo Hershey’s© Cream Ice Cream Pie: $22
🍦 7″ Turtle Cream Hershey’s© Ice Cream Pie: $22
🍦 7″ Peanut Butter Love Me Hershey’s© Ice Cream Pie: $22
🍦 7″ Custom Hershey’s© Ice Cream Pie Cream Pie
(Your choice of one in-stock ice cream flavor): $22

Scoops Ice Cream

Contact Info


Follow Us

Get InTouch